Beyond the HSG: A Closer Look at Your Uterine Health
Updated: 11 hours ago

You had your hysterosalpingogram (HSG) on a Tuesday morning. You remember the cramping, watching the monitor, and waiting for the radiologist to tell you whether your fallopian tubes were open.
Then came the good news: Both tubes were open. Everything looked normal.
You went home relieved, thinking you'd crossed another possible explanation off your list.
Three months later, you're staring at another negative pregnancy test.
Your hormone levels are normal. Your partner's semen analysis came back normal. You've been tracking ovulation, timing intercourse, and doing everything you're supposed to do.
So why aren't you pregnant?
Here's something worth understanding: A normal HSG provides valuable information, but it doesn't rule out every possible issue inside your uterus.
What Does a Normal HSG Actually Tell You?
An HSG is an X-ray procedure that uses contrast dye to evaluate your uterus and fallopian tubes. Its primary purpose is to determine whether your fallopian tubes are open, allowing sperm and egg to potentially meet.The test also provides information about the shape of your uterine cavity and may identify structural abnormalities.
When your doctor says your HSG is normal, that's encouraging news. It generally means the dye passed through your fallopian tubes and no obvious abnormalities were identified.But here's an important distinction: Confirming that your tubes are open isn't the same as ruling out every abnormality within your uterine cavity.
And that distinction may matter when you're struggling with unexplained infertility.
What Can an HSG Miss Inside Your Uterus?
Your uterine cavity is lined with the endometrium, the tissue that thickens and changes throughout your menstrual cycle in preparation for a possible pregnancy.
Certain structural abnormalities can affect the cavity, including:
Endometrial polyps: Growths of tissue that develop from the uterine lining.
Submucosal fibroids: Noncancerous growths that extend into or distort the uterine cavity.
Intrauterine adhesions: Bands of scar tissue that can develop following uterine procedures, infection, or other injury.
An HSG may identify these abnormalities, but smaller lesions can be more difficult to detect or characterize.
According to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), HSG has approximately 50% sensitivity for detecting endometrial polyps and submucosal fibroids in asymptomatic women experiencing infertility.
In practical terms, that means an HSG may miss some of these findings.
This doesn't mean your HSG was performed incorrectly or that an abnormality is necessarily present. It simply means different diagnostic tests provide different levels of detail.
Saline Sonogram vs. Hysteroscopy: What's the Difference?
If your fertility specialist suspects a uterine cavity abnormality, two procedures may provide additional information.
Saline Infusion Sonography (SIS)
Also called a saline sonogram or sonohysterography, this procedure uses ultrasound and sterile saline to evaluate the inside of your uterus.
A small amount of saline is introduced through the cervix, gently expanding the uterine cavity. This helps your provider see the uterine lining more clearly and identify abnormalities that may be difficult to visualize with a standard ultrasound or HSG.
ASRM reports that saline sonography has greater than 90% positive and negative predictive values for identifying certain intrauterine abnormalities, including polyps, submucosal fibroids, and adhesions.
The procedure is generally performed in an outpatient setting and does not require surgery.
Hysteroscopy
A hysteroscopy takes the evaluation one step further. Instead of relying on imaging alone, your physician inserts a thin camera through the cervix to directly visualize the uterine cavity.
This allows for a closer examination of the uterine lining and, when appropriate, the ability to remove certain abnormalities or obtain tissue samples.Hysteroscopy is considered the definitive method for diagnosing and treating many intrauterine abnormalities.
However, because it's more invasive than an ultrasound-based evaluation, it isn't automatically recommended for everyone.
Does Every Woman With a Normal HSG Need Additional Testing?
No. And this is where individualized fertility care becomes especially important.
A normal HSG is a meaningful part of your fertility evaluation. In many circumstances, additional uterine cavity testing may not be necessary.
However, further evaluation may be worth discussing if you have:
Persistent abnormal uterine bleeding or spotting between periods.
A history of uterine surgery or procedures that could increase the risk of adhesions.
Recurrent pregnancy loss.
An ultrasound or HSG finding that requires clarification.
Your symptoms, medical history, previous imaging, age, and overall fertility evaluation all help determine whether another test would provide useful information.
It's also important to recognize that identifying a uterine abnormality doesn't automatically mean you've discovered the reason you haven't conceived. The potential impact depends on the type, size, and location of the finding, and treatment does not guarantee pregnancy.
The goal isn't to order every available test. It's to understand which evaluations are clinically appropriate for your circumstances.
Three Questions to Ask Your Fertility Specialist
If you've been diagnosed with unexplained infertility and your HSG was normal, consider bringing these questions to your next appointment:
1. Did my HSG adequately evaluate my uterine cavity, or was its main finding that my fallopian tubes were open?
Ask your specialist to review the actual report and explain what was assessed.
2. Based on my symptoms and medical history, would a saline sonogram provide any additional useful information?
This helps determine whether more detailed imaging is warranted rather than assuming everyone needs another procedure.
3. If we identify a small polyp or fibroid, would treating it meaningfully change my fertility management?
Not every abnormality requires intervention. Understanding whether a finding would influence your treatment plan is just as important as identifying it.
Normal Results Are Reassuring. But Understanding Them Matters.
After more than 15 years working in fertility care, one thing I've learned is that receiving a normal test result and understanding what that result means are two very different things.
If you've been trying to conceive for months without answers, it's understandable to wonder whether something has been overlooked.
But unexplained infertility doesn't automatically mean there's a hidden problem waiting to be discovered.
Sometimes the most valuable next step isn't another test. It's taking a closer look at the information you already have, identifying what has been evaluated, and understanding which questions are still worth asking.
That's why I created my free guide, 10 Fertility Patterns Hiding in Your "Normal" Results.
It's designed to help you recognize patterns in your menstrual cycle, laboratory results, and reproductive health history so you can have more informed conversations with your fertility care team.
Because when your results are normal but you're still not pregnant, you deserve more than another month of unanswered questions.
References
American Society for Reproductive Medicine. (2021). Fertility evaluation of infertile women: A committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility, 116(5), 1255–1265.https://www.asrm.org/practice-guidance/practice-committee-documents/fertility-evaluation-of-infertile-women-a-committee-opinion-2021/
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Sonohysterography.https://www.acog.org/womens-health/faqs/sonohysterography
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. (2020). The use of hysteroscopy for the diagnosis and treatment of intrauterine pathology. Committee Opinion No. 800.https://www.acog.org/clinical/clinical-guidance/committee-opinion/articles/2020/03/the-use-of-hysteroscopy-for-the-diagnosis-and-treatment-of-intrauterine-pathology



Comments